Skip to content
logo horizontal
logo tree only
logo tree only
  • about
      • About us
        • Vision Generic_YEG Feature art
      • Times & Directions
        • Watch us online 2023 169hd web
      • Staff & Leadership
        • Team Web Rotator
      • Worship
        • Worship-arts-169HD-sm2
      • Membership
        • Fall 2025 Class NO QR
      • Baptism
        • Interested in Baptism 169HD
      • Communion
        • Communion 169HD
      • Baby Dedication
        • Baby dedication2 169HD
      • New Believers
        • Care,Of,New,Life,-,Watering,Young,Plant,-,Vintage
      • Meet With A Pastor
        • Living,Room,With,Two,Yellow,Armchair,mockup,Concrete,Wall.3d,Rendering
      • Sermon Series
        • Detoxicity 169hd
        • Up Next:
  • ministries
      • Family
        • Happy,Family,In,The,Park,Evening,Light.,The,Lights,Of
      • Kids
        • MBC KIDS Postcard 169HD
      • Teens
        • admin-ajax-rgb
        • Fresh wave Podcast Logo Full
      • Adults
        • small groups 2017 HD16
        • Adult-Sunday-School 2018 169HD
        • Womens min winter 2024
        • Mens Ministries 2018 169HD
        • Young Adult 2020 16.9HD generic no dates
        • Master_senior 3rd_Fri_ lunch slide 16.9HD
        • Men,Supporting,Men,,Introduction,To,A,Men’s,Therapy,Group
      • Missions
        • Missions Logo new page2 169HD
        • Senegal Missions banner 169HD 2021
        • 1st Choice 169HD
        • City Relief 16.9
        • market Street Mission 169HD
        • Feedng Hands
      • Care
        • Care team 2015 169hd
      • Internships
        • Internships
      • Underground Sessions
        • Underground Sess. Signage
      • Stephen Ministry
        • Stephen Ministry 2017 169HD
      • Little Footprints Learning Center
        • LFLC Postcard 2017 V2
  • media
      • Sunday Worship Playlist & Sermon Outline
        • Worship arts logo copy
      • Digital Ministry
        • Podcasts Feature GRaphic2
        • Move to YT Livestream MBC UNHINDERED noDate-169 copy
      • Pastor’s Table Blog
        • RTR PTB
      • Behind the Pulpit
        • Behind the Pulpit weekly YouTube 169 V2 Rach. no text
      • Fresh Wave
        • Fresh wave Podcast Logo Full
      • Wednesdays in the Word
        • Weds in the Word v1
      • Sermon Archive
        • Sermon Archive Banner
      • Right Now Media
        • church_slide_1
      • Merch Store
        • MBC Merch store 169 reg copy
  • events
  • prayer
      • Praise & Prayer Weekly Update
        • Prayer Web 169hd
      • Men and Women’s Prayer Room
        • ladies and mens prayer graphic copy
  • give
      • Year-End Giving for 2025
        • 2025 Giving
      • MBC Giving
        • MBC Giving Slides_template 10 digit 2021b
      • Serving
        • Ministry Page feature graphic 169
  • connect
      • Getting Connected
        • Newsletter,Email,Icon,Isolated,On,Special,Blue,Banner,Background,Abstract
      • The Bridge
        • Bridge Sep 28 2025 V2
      • Shared Interest Groups
        • Shared Interest Groups 169
      • Share your Gifts
        • Serving page alt With Webpage URL 169
      • Finance Team
        • Finance Team 169
      • Safety & Security Team
        • Safety&Security 16×9 V1
      • Buildings & Grounds Team
        • Buildings & Grounds Team 16×9 V3
      • Hospitality Team
        • Hospitality Team 16×9 FINAL
  • log in
PrevPrevious EntryGuidelines for God’s Family (1 Timothy 5:1-16)
Next EntryHow To Avoid Money Love (1 Timothy 6:3-10)Next

BACK TO THE PASTOR’S TABLE

Leadership Integrity

Listen to this article

By Pastor Dave Hentschel | June 15, 2025

1 Tim 5.17-6.2

This week, a familiar name in Christian music made headlines—Michael Tait, lead singer of the Newsboys and former member of DC Talk, publicly admitted to recent allegations of sexual misconduct and substance abuse. His confession brought a flood of emotions, not least because of a haunting DC Talk song from 1995: “What If I Stumble?”

The chorus still echoes:

“What if I stumble? What if I fall?
What if I lose my step and make fools of us all?”

The song opens with Brennan Manning’s stark quote:

“The greatest single cause of atheism in the world today is Christians who acknowledge Jesus with their lips, walk out the door, and deny Him by their lifestyle.”

Nearly 30 years later, those lyrics feel less like a warning and more like a lament. Michael Tait has stumbled. Kevin Max has walked away from the faith. TobyMac has endured deep personal loss. Brennan Manning, whose voice introduces the track, battled addiction much of his life. These aren’t abstract failures—they’re real people, with real wounds, in real need of grace.

And that brings us to 1 Timothy 5:17–6:2, a passage where the apostle Paul speaks directly to the heart of Christian integrity, especially in leadership—but also in everyday life.

  1. Leaders and Compensation (1 Tim. 5:17–18)

Paul begins by saying that elders who lead well should be considered “worthy of double honor”—which includes both respect and financial support. Those who labor in preaching and teaching deserve provision, not neglect.

  1. Leaders and Accusation (1 Tim. 5:19–21)

Paul also acknowledges the unique vulnerability of leaders: they can become targets for false accusations, or worse—untouchable when sin is real. That’s why he lays out clear boundaries:

  • Don’t receive a charge without evidence.
  • But if sin is confirmed, it must be dealt with publicly and without partiality.

Integrity is not just about guarding a leader’s reputation—it’s about guarding the church’s witness. Integrity builds trust. Hypocrisy destroys it.

  1. Leaders and Ordination (1 Tim. 5:22–25)

Paul warns Timothy: don’t be hasty in laying on hands. Don’t rush leadership decisions. Why? Because a person’s character is like the tide—it eventually shows itself. Some sins are obvious, others hidden. But in time, everything comes to light.

  1. Leaders and Vocation (1 Tim. 6:1–2)

At first glance, it seems odd that Paul shifts to talking about bondservants and masters—but there’s a theme running through it: how we live out our faith in daily work matters.

Paul says those who work under authority should show respect—not just to honor people, but to honor God. Why? Because our witness is always on display. The gospel doesn’t just transform our beliefs—it transforms our behavior, including how we work, lead, and respond to those in authority.

Integrity vs. Hypocrisy

If we had to sum up the theme of this passage in one word, it’s integrity—being the same in public and private, in belief and behavior. And the opposite of integrity? Hypocrisy—pretending to be one thing while living another.

Paul’s concern is not just about church structure—it’s about spiritual health. Because when integrity collapses, trust is broken and the gospel is tarnished. That’s true for pastors. It’s true for fathers. It’s true for every follower of Jesus.

What If I Stumble?

Let’s go back to that song. “What if I stumble? What if I fall?” The truth is—we will. You will. I will. Every leader, every father, every Christian stumbles at some point.

But integrity isn’t about never stumbling. It’s about how we respond when we do. Do we hide it? Spin it? Minimize it? Or do we own it? Confess it? Repent and get back up, clinging to grace?

Whether you’re leading in a church, a business, or a home—your integrity matters. The gospel calls us to be the same person behind the scenes as we are in public.

Let’s be men—and women—who walk in integrity, so that when the question comes: “What if I stumble?”—we can answer with the cross. There’s grace. There’s restoration. And there’s strength to get back up.

Picture of Dave Hentschel

Dave Hentschel

David Hentschel serves as Lead Pastor: Preaching, Spiritual Formation and Care at Millington Baptist Church in Basking Ridge, NJ. He is a graduate of Philadelphia Biblical University and Dallas Theological Seminary. He and his wife Juli enjoy three children.
PrevPrevious EntryGuidelines for God’s Family (1 Timothy 5:1-16)
Next EntryHow To Avoid Money Love (1 Timothy 6:3-10)Next

BACK TO THE PASTOR’S TABLE

Like what you see? Sign up to receive notifications from The Pastor's Table!
Loading
Like what you see? Sign up to receive notifications from The Pastor's Table!
Loading

Recent Entries

Loading...

God With Us: The Near and Far Fulfillment of Isaiah 7:14

September 29, 2025
/
Dave Hentschel
“Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign: The virgin will conceive and give birth to a son, and will call him Immanuel.” (Isaiah 7:14) Isaiah 7:14 is one of the most famous prophecies in all of Scripture, quoted directly in Matthew’s Gospel as fulfilled in the birth of...
Read More

The God of Dangerous Beauty

September 24, 2025
/
Bob Erbig
Dangerous Beauty: Encountering God’s Holiness Isaiah 6 is one of those passages many of us know well. We’ve heard it in sermons, sung parts of it in worship songs, and maybe even memorized a few verses. But let me challenge you—don’t let the familiarity dull your sense of awe. This...
Read More

The Invitation of Grace

September 16, 2025
/
Dave Hentschel
A devotional on Isaiah 1:18 "Come now, let us reason together, says the Lord: though your sins are like scarlet, they shall be as white as snow; though they are red like crimson, they shall become like wool." (Isa 1:18, ESV) Isaiah 1 opens with a strong rebuke—God’s people have...
Read More

The View from the Mountaintop: Introduction to the book of Isaiah

September 8, 2025
/
Dave Hentschel
The View from the Mountaintop (Introduction to the book of Isaiah) Climbing a mountain takes effort, but it also gives you a breathtaking view. That’s what the prophet Isaiah offers us: a higher perspective on God, ourselves, and the world. When we open his book, we’re not just reading ancient...
Read More

Fight The Good Fight (1 Timothy 6:11-16)

July 14, 2025
/
Bob Erbig
The Spiritual Battle for a Healthy Church This was an important series for our church as we approach our 175th Anniversary next year. For a church to last 175 years, the principals in 1 Timothy must be present. We’ve learned how to combat false teaching, how to make the Gospel...
Read More

Why We’re Baptists: Convictions That Shape Our Church

July 7, 2025
/
Dave Hentschel
Sermon Summary July 6, 2025 In the early 1500s, a German farmer named Fritz Erbe was imprisoned in a dungeon for refusing to baptize his infant son. He believed baptism should follow personal faith, and for that conviction, he spent 16 years in isolation—never once wavering. His courage reminds us...
Read More
1 2 … 31 Next »

God With Us: The Near and Far Fulfillment of Isaiah 7:14

“Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign: The virgin will conceive and give birth to a son, and will call him Immanuel.” (Isaiah 7:14) Isaiah 7:14 is one of the most famous prophecies in all of Scripture, quoted directly in Matthew’s Gospel as fulfilled in the birth of Christ. But like many Old

Read More
Dave Hentschel September 29, 2025

The God of Dangerous Beauty

Dangerous Beauty: Encountering God’s Holiness Isaiah 6 is one of those passages many of us know well. We’ve heard it in sermons, sung parts of it in worship songs, and maybe even memorized a few verses. But let me challenge you—don’t let the familiarity dull your sense of awe. This chapter is meant to shake

Read More
Bob Erbig September 24, 2025

The Invitation of Grace

A devotional on Isaiah 1:18 “Come now, let us reason together, says the Lord: though your sins are like scarlet, they shall be as white as snow; though they are red like crimson, they shall become like wool.” (Isa 1:18, ESV) Isaiah 1 opens with a strong rebuke—God’s people have turned away, they have neglected

Read More
Dave Hentschel September 16, 2025
Page1 Page2 Page3 Page4 Page5
  • www.millingtonbaptist.org
  • mbc@millingtonbaptist.org
  • /millingtonchurch
  • /MBCNewJersey
  • www.millingtonbaptist.org
  • mbc@millingtonbaptist.org
  • facebook.com/millingtonchurch
  • twitter.com/MBCNewJersey
  • 520 King George Road | Basking Ridge, NJ 07920 | 908-647-0594
  • about
    • Back
    • About us
      • Back
      • Back
    • Times & Directions
      • Back
      • Back
    • Staff & Leadership
      • Back
      • Back
    • Worship
      • Back
      • Back
    • Membership
      • Back
      • Back
    • Baptism
      • Back
      • Back
    • Communion
      • Back
      • Communion
      • Back
    • Baby Dedication
      • Back
      • Baby Dedications
      • Back
    • New Believers
      • Back
      • New Believers
      • Back
    • Meet With A Pastor
      • Back
      • Meet With A Pastor
      • Back
    • Sermon Series
      • Back
      • Back
    • Back
  • ministries
    • Back
    • Family
      • Back
      • Family Ministries
      • Back
    • Kids
      • Back
      • MBC Kids
      • Back
    • Teens
      • Back
      • Teens
      • The Fresh Wave Podcast
      • Back
    • Adults
      • Back
      • Small Groups
      • Adult Education
      • Women
      • Men
      • Young Adults
      • Senior Luncheon
      • Radical Mentoring
      • Back
    • Missions
      • Back
      • MBC Missions
      • Senegal
      • First Choice
      • City Relief
      • Market Street Mission
      • Feeding Hands
      • Back
    • Care
      • Back
      • Back
    • Internships
      • Back
      • Internships
      • Back
    • Underground Sessions
      • Back
      • Underground Sessions
      • Back
    • Stephen Ministry
      • Back
      • Back
    • Little Footprints Learning Center
      • Back
      • Back
    • Back
  • media
    • Back
    • Sunday Worship Playlist & Sermon Outline
      • Back
      • Sunday Worship Playlist & Sermon Outline
      • Back
    • Digital Ministry
      • Back
      • Digital Ministry
      • Livestream
      • Back
    • Pastor’s Table Blog
      • Back
      • Pastor’s Table Blog
      • Back
    • Behind the Pulpit
      • Back
      • Updates & Connection Opportunities
      • Back
    • Fresh Wave
      • Back
      • The Fresh Wave Podcast
      • Back
    • Wednesdays in the Word
      • Back
      • Wednesdays in the Word
      • Back
    • Sermon Archive
      • Back
      • Sermon Archive
      • Back
    • Right Now Media
      • Back
      • Right Now Media
      • Back
    • Merch Store
      • Back
      • Merch Store
      • Back
    • Back
  • events
  • prayer
    • Back
    • Praise & Prayer Weekly Update
      • Back
      • Praise & Prayer Weekly Update
      • Back
    • Men and Women’s Prayer Room
      • Back
      • Men and Women’s Prayer Room
      • Back
    • Back
  • give
    • Back
    • Year-End Giving for 2025
      • Back
      • Year-End Giving for 2025
      • Back
    • MBC Giving
      • Back
      • give
      • Back
    • Serving
      • Back
      • Share your Gifts
      • Back
    • Back
  • connect
    • Back
    • Getting Connected
      • Back
      • getting connected
      • Back
    • The Bridge
      • Back
      • The Bridge – September 28th, 2025
      • Back
    • Shared Interest Groups
      • Back
      • Shared Interest Groups
      • Back
    • Share your Gifts
      • Back
      • Share your Gifts
      • Back
    • Finance Team
      • Back
      • MBC Finance Team
      • Back
    • Safety & Security Team
      • Back
      • MBC Safety & Security Team
      • Back
    • Buildings & Grounds Team
      • Back
      • MBC Buildings & Grounds Team
      • Back
    • Hospitality Team
      • Back
      • MBC Hospitality Team
      • Back
    • Back
  • log in