Skip to content
logo horizontal
logo tree only
logo tree only
  • about
      • Sermon Series
        • Philip Joy 169 HD
        • Up Next:
      • Times & Directions
        • Generic Sunday Service times 2021 169hd
      • About us
        • Vision Feature art grey 2022 169
      • Getting Connected
        • Newsletter,Email,Icon,Isolated,On,Special,Blue,Banner,Background,Abstract
      • Meet With A Pastor
        • Living,Room,With,Two,Yellow,Armchair,mockup,Concrete,Wall.3d,Rendering
      • New Believers
        • Care,Of,New,Life,-,Watering,Young,Plant,-,Vintage
      • Worship
        • Worship-arts-169HD-sm2
      • Baptism
        • Interested in Baptism 169HD
      • Baby Dedications
        • Baby dedication2 169HD
      • Communion
        • Communion 169HD
      • Membership
        • mbc membership
      • COVID 19 Campus Info
        • COVID-19 UPdates
      • Staff & Leadership
        • Team Web Rotator
  • ministries
      • Internships
        • Internships
      • Family Ministries
        • Happy,Family,In,The,Park,Evening,Light.,The,Lights,Of
      • Kids
        • MBC KIDS Postcard 169HD
      • Teens
        • Summer Schedule 2022 169
        • Wednesdays the Rush
        • blog menu
      • Adults
        • Feet,In,Leather,Sneaker,On,Pavement,Background,,Top,View
        • small groups 2018 HD16
        • womens Feature Image 2018 Web 16.9HD
        • Adult-Sunday-School 2018 169HD
        • Young Adult SundayWeekly22 16.9HD
        • senior-luncheon-master-16.9HD
        • Mens Ministries 2018 169HD
        • Men,Supporting,Men,,Introduction,To,A,Men’s,Therapy,Group
      • Underground Sessions
        • Underground Sess. Signage
      • Care
        • Care team 2015 169hd
      • Divorce Care
        • DivorcCare 169HD
      • Stephen Ministry
        • Stephen Ministry 2017 169HD
      • Missions – World Partners
        • Missions Logo new page2 169HD
        • Senegal Missions banner 169HD 2021
        • 1st Choice 169HD
        • city relief 169HD-MBC-COMMS-LAPTOP2020
        • market Street Mission 169HD
        • Feedng Hands
      • MBC Unhindered
        • Unhindered 169hd
      • Little Footprints Learning Center
        • LFLC Postcard 2017 V2
  • media
      • Pastors Weekly Video
        • Behind the Pulpit
      • Pastor’s Table Blog
        • Pastor’s Table 169hd
      • Sunday Service Live Stream
        • Live Stream 169HD 2020 9am no time
      • YouTube Channel
        • Subscribe to MBC UNHINDERED Congregation 169
      • Sermon Archive
        • Sermon Archive Banner
  • events
  • prayer
  • give
      • MBC Giving
        • MBC Giving Slides_template 10 digit 2021b
      • Year-End Giving for 2023
        • MBC VISION 2022 building blocks
      • Give Your Time & Efforts
        • Serving page alt 2 169
      • Give Help, Get Help
        • Give Get 169hd 2021
      • Support Ukraine
        • Support Ukraine 169
  • connect
      • Getting Connected
        • Newsletter,Email,Icon,Isolated,On,Special,Blue,Banner,Background,Abstract
      • Shared Interest Groups
        • Shared Interest Groups 169
      • Share your Gifts
        • Serving page alt With Webpage URL 169
  • log in
PrevPrevious EntryTop Five Lessons from the Book of Hebrews
Next EntryRoe v. Wade is Overturned: How should Christians respond?Next

BACK TO THE PASTOR’S TABLE

Aren’t Christianity and Science Incompatible?

We are going through a sermon series at church discussing different worldviews. Many people in our culture believe that faith and science are opposed to one another. They see them as either mutually exclusive or even incompatible. I want to argue that that they are not only compatible, but they are locked together in a logical sequence. In this essay, I will argue that modern scientific inquiry was built on top of the doctrines of Christian Theism.

Dr. Rebekah McLaughlin in her excellent book “Confronting Christianity”[1] points out that Dr. Hans Halvorson who is a professor of philosophy at Princeton, argues that not only did Christians throughout history invent science, but the reason they invented science was because they saw in the Scriptures a Creator God who is both rational and free.[2] In other words, when they looked around, they saw a God who provided order and who created principles or laws which govern the universe, such that we as His creatures might be able to discern these things. They believed nature was uniform and could be trusted to behave in predictable ways. But, since God is free, He could do this however He wanted to. Therefore, the only way to find out what those underlying rules are, is to “go and look.”

What the history of science suggests is that science assumes the existence of natural laws and presupposes the constancy of nature, but on what basis? I assert these assumptions of science stand on the foundation of Theism. Christians believe that God is unchanging (Mal 3:6) and that He governs nature by fixed patterns. (Gen 8:22) We believe He has entrusted us with stewardship and responsibility and given us language, senses and reasoning to live in His world. One intertestamental writer said it this way, “Thou hast ordered all things in measure and number and weight” (Wisdom of Solomon 11.20). To do science (as Johannes Kepler said) is to “think God’s thoughts after Him.” The scientific achievements of Isaac Newton (1642-1727) were summarized in poet Alexander Pope’s famous couplet:

“Nature and Nature’s laws lay hid in night

God said: ‘Let Newton be!” and all was light.”

Pope’s point is clear, that Newton discovered some of the fundamental laws of nature as given by God. Research professor Peter Harrison writes,

“What is often less appreciated, however, is that part of the novelty of Newton’s achievement lay in his conviction that there were laws of nature there in the first place, awaiting discovery…This idea – laws of nature in the scientific sense – was an innovation of the seventeenth century and was a consequence of the extension of God’s legislative moral power to the physical world. One of the pioneers of this new understanding of laws of nature was the French philosopher and scientist Rene Descartes (1596-1650), who wrote that “God alone is the author of all the motions in the world. Descartes thus argued that because these laws had their source in an eternal and unchanging God, the laws of nature must themselves be eternal and unchanging. Descartes also set out a law of the conservation of motion, again arguing for it on the basis of God’s immutability. This idea that nature was governed by constant and immutable principles was an important precondition for experimental science…Robert Boyle, the father of modern chemistry and author of the eponymous law, observed that God’s creation operates according to fixed laws “which He alone at first established.” God’s authorship of the laws of nature guaranteed their universality and unchanging nature.” [3]

The problem (for the secular scientist) is that science itself is based on these inherently Christian presuppositions. In other words, science is only possible because of the assumption that an unchanging God upholds the universe in this logical, orderly way. This same God made our minds able to think and reason logically. We assume nature’s laws (such as the law of gravity) and the laws of logic (such as the law of non-contradiction), but without God, people do so without accounting for them.

In other words, without a belief in God, we run into what’s called in philosophy the “problem of induction.” This problem asks the following questions: 1) What are the justifications, if any, for any knowledge beyond our mere observations? 2) How can anyone generalize based on a number of finite observations? 3) On what basis can we assume that the future will occur as it always has in the past? Philosopher David Hume argued that our reason alone cannot even establish the grounds of proving cause and effect. Hume presented this problem of induction in his work “A Treatise of Human Nature,” writing this:

“There can be no demonstrative arguments to prove, that those instances, of which we have had no experience, resemble those, of which we have had experience.”[4]

Where can we go to determine with any degree of certainty that empiricism (the reliance on the senses for information) is a trustworthy source of knowledge? And furthermore, where can we go to determine with any degree of certainty that rationalism (our ability to use logic and reason) is a verifiable source of knowledge? We are left with complete uncertainty without God’s promises. But this leaves us with a world in which no one can live consistently.

“If the foundations are destroyed, what can the righteous do?” (Ps 11:3, ESV)

Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) is responsible for introducing the term “transcendental” to philosophical discussion. All of us, he argued, must concede that knowledge is possible. Or else, there is no point to any discussion or inquiry. Now, given that knowledge is possible, said Kant, we should ask what the conditions are that make knowledge possible. What must the world be like, and what must the workings of our minds be like, if human knowledge is to be possible? The Transcendental argument became a staple of the writings of the idealist school that followed Kant, and from there it made its way into Christian apologetics. James Orr (1844-1913) employed it. But the twentieth-century apologist who placed the most weight on the transcendental argument (which he sometimes called “reasoning by presupposition”) was Dr. Cornelius Van Til (1895-1987) of Westminster Seminary. He, along with many of his students (Dr. Greg Bahnsen, Dr. John Frame, Dr. Scoff Oliphant) argued for the truth of Christian Theism based on “the Transcendental Argument for God.” (T.A.G.) Van Til would say that only Christianity provides the necessary preconditions for rational and scientific thought. He maintained that Christian theism is the presupposition of all meaning, all rational significance, and all intelligible discourse. Even when someone argues against Christian theism, Van Til said, he presupposes it, for he presupposes that rational argument is possible and that truth can be conveyed through language. The non-Christian, then, in Van Til’s famous illustration, is like a child sitting on her father’s lap, slapping his face. She could not slap him unless he supported her. Similarly, the non-Christian cannot carry out his rebellion against God unless God makes that rebellion possible. Contradicting God assumes an intelligible universe and therefore a theistic one.[5] The sure proof that God exists, Van Til would argue, is that “without Him, you can’t prove anything.”[6] His proof of God was based on “the impossibility of the contrary.”

This does not mean that secular scientists cannot make observations, use reason and do science, they can. But, they can do so only because they too live in God’s trustworthy world. The transcendental argument simply means that they have no philosophical justification for doing science. In other words, when scientists presuppose the laws of nature being uniform, they are borrowing from the Christian worldview (truth that comes from outside of the worldview of naturalistic materialism) when making these assumptions.

Evidence of the necessity of these assumptions can be found in the Bible, such as in Proverbs 1:7, “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge.” And, “All the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are hidden in Christ.” (Col 2:3) The Bible does make this kind of radical claim, that creation not only implies, but presupposes God. We must start with God, lest we become fools. (Ps 14:1, Rom 1:18-25, 1 Cor 1:20) For God is the creator of all, and therefore the source of all meaning, order, and intelligibility. It is in Christ that all things hold together (Col. 1:17). So without him everything falls apart; nothing makes sense. Therefore, the Bible teaches that God is not a God who is reasoned to, rather He is THE God that we (as finite human beings), simply cannot reason without. Belief in this Creator God who has revealed Himself through special revelation and most clearly in the person of Jesus Christ serves as a firm foundation for all of life and for scientific inquiry.

C.S. Lewis once said, “I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen: not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else.”[7]

Everyone must start with assumptions when doing science, but only scientists from a Christian worldview have justification for doing so. Scientists who come from a Christian worldview can account for such knowledge and certainty based on the belief that God has revealed Himself as the trustworthy Creator and sustainer of all His creation. (Col 1:1-20)

 

(To learn more about these important worldview issues such as the relationship between science and faith, visit our sermon series webpage here.)


 

References:

Bahnsen, Greg, Always Ready: Directions for Defending the Faith (Atlanta: American Vision, 1996).

Frame, John, Apologetics to the Glory of God (Phillipsburg, NJ: P & R Publishing, 1994).

Frame, John, Cornelius Van Til (Phillipsburg, NJ: P & R Publishing, 1995).

Lewis, C.S. Mere Christianity. (New York: Macmillan, 1960).

McLaughlin, Rebecca. Confronting Christianity (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2019),

Oliphant, Scott. Covenantal Apologetics (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2013).

Pratt, Richard. Every Thought Captive: A Study Manual for the Defense of Christian Truth (Phillipsburgh, NJ, P & R Publishing, 1979).

Kant, Immanuel, Critique of Pure Reason, abridged, ed., tr., int.  by Norman Kemp Smith (N. Y.: 1958).

Van Til, Cornelius, The Defense of the Faith (Philadelphia: 1963).

Works Cited: 

[1] McLaughlin, Rebecca. Confronting Christianity (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2019), Ch. 7.

[2] Prof. Hans Halvorson, “Does the Universe Need God?” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDwpTcSEjak Accessed July 14, 2021.

[3] Peter Harrison is a Research Professor at University of Queensland and a Senior Research Fellow at the Ian Ramsay Centre in Oxford, where for a number of years he was the Idreos Professor of Science and Religion. He has published many books on the history of science and is editor of The Cambridge Companion to Science and Religion. Quotation taken from https://www.abc.net.au/religion/christianity-and-the-rise-of-western-science/10100570 Accessed July 14, 2021.

[4] For more basic information about this philosophical problem, visit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem_of_induction

[5] Van Til, Cornelius, The Defense of the Faith (Philadelphia: 1963).

[6] Van Til, Cornelius, The Defense of the Faith (Philadelphia: 1963).

[7] C.S. Lewis. Mere Christianity (New York: Macmillan, 1960).

Dave Hentschel

Dave Hentschel

David Hentschel serves as Lead Pastor: Preaching, Spiritual Formation and Care at Millington Baptist Church in Basking Ridge, NJ. He is a graduate of Philadelphia Biblical University and Dallas Theological Seminary. He and his wife Juli enjoy three children.
PrevPrevious EntryTop Five Lessons from the Book of Hebrews
Next EntryRoe v. Wade is Overturned: How should Christians respond?Next

BACK TO THE PASTOR’S TABLE

Like what you see? Sign up to receive notifications from The Pastor's Table!
Loading
Like what you see? Sign up to receive notifications from The Pastor's Table!
Loading

Recent Entries

Loading...

Righteousness through Faith

May 30, 2023
/
Noah Graves
  In Philippians 3:1-11, the Apostle Paul talks about righteousness. But, this begs the question, why is he talking about righteousness in the middle of the book of Philippians? What does righteousness have to do with joy? Well, there was a group of people causing issues amongst many of the...
Read More

Savor the Sweet Sacrifice (Philippians 2:17)

May 18, 2023
/
Bob Erbig
  Bob Erbig: Savor the sweet sacrifice of Christ, but also the sacrifice he calls us to. You may remember that in Romans 12:1-2 Paul calls us to be a living sacrifice for Christ. To conclude the section, Paul shows us what this looks like in verse 17: "But even...
Read More

How Does Sanctification Work?

May 15, 2023
/
Bob Erbig
A Lesson From Liquid Glass The spiritual formation of a Christian is not something that happens overnight. We are saved in an instant through our justification. However, conforming our lives to the image of our Savior Jesus Christ—that takes a lifetime. It is the process theologians call sanctification. To illustrate...
Read More

The Enemy of Unity

May 11, 2023
/
Bob Erbig
  By: Pastor Bob Erbig Now practically speaking, humble bragging has nothing to do with being humble. When you humblebrag you are either: (1) Complaining about something. (2) Boasting about something. (3) Or it is some combination of both. Often, people will publicly complain about something being so difficult, "my...
Read More

Avoiding the “Humblebrag”: Thoughts on Philippians 2:1-11

May 9, 2023
/
Bob Erbig
The Lie of the Humble-Brag Now, humility, or the idea of being humble is a mixed bag in our culture. Too many people, in our culture, use the guise of humility to brag about their accomplishments. There is word for that: The HUMBLE-BRAG. This phenomenon has nothing to do with...
Read More

4.30.23 Sermon Summary

May 2, 2023
/
Dave Hentschel
How do I live like a Christian? Text: Phil 1:27-30 Date: 4/30/2023 By: Pastor Dave Hentschel Philippians 1:27-30 is a passage from the New Testament of the Bible, specifically from the book of Philippians. Here is the passage in the New International Version (NIV): "Whatever happens, conduct yourselves in a...
Read More
1 2 … 10 Next »

Righteousness through Faith

  In Philippians 3:1-11, the Apostle Paul talks about righteousness. But, this begs the question, why is he talking about righteousness in the middle of the book of Philippians? What does righteousness have to do with joy? Well, there was a group of people causing issues amongst many of the early Christians. And that group

Read More
Noah Graves May 30, 2023

Savor the Sweet Sacrifice (Philippians 2:17)

  Bob Erbig: Savor the sweet sacrifice of Christ, but also the sacrifice he calls us to. You may remember that in Romans 12:1-2 Paul calls us to be a living sacrifice for Christ. To conclude the section, Paul shows us what this looks like in verse 17: “But even if I am being poured

Read More
Bob Erbig May 18, 2023

How Does Sanctification Work?

A Lesson From Liquid Glass The spiritual formation of a Christian is not something that happens overnight. We are saved in an instant through our justification. However, conforming our lives to the image of our Savior Jesus Christ—that takes a lifetime. It is the process theologians call sanctification. To illustrate this process I invite you

Read More
Bob Erbig May 15, 2023
Page1 Page2 Page3 Page4 Page5
  • www.millingtonbaptist.org
  • mbc@millingtonbaptist.org
  • /millingtonchurch
  • /MBCNewJersey
  • www.millingtonbaptist.org
  • mbc@millingtonbaptist.org
  • facebook.com/millingtonchurch
  • twitter.com/MBCNewJersey
  • 520 King George Road | Basking Ridge, NJ 07920 | 908-647-0594
  • about
    • Back
    • Sermon Series
      • Back
      • Back
    • Times & Directions
      • Back
      • Back
    • About us
      • Back
      • Back
    • Getting Connected
      • Back
      • Getting Connected
      • Back
    • Meet With A Pastor
      • Back
      • Meet With A Pastor
      • Back
    • New Believers
      • Back
      • New Believers
      • Back
    • Worship
      • Back
      • Back
    • Baptism
      • Back
      • Back
    • Baby Dedications
      • Back
      • Baby Dedications
      • Back
    • Communion
      • Back
      • Communion
      • Back
    • Membership
      • Back
      • Back
    • COVID 19 Campus Info
      • Back
      • MBC Indoor Gathering Plan, 9am & 10:15am
      • Back
    • Staff & Leadership
      • Back
      • Back
    • Back
  • ministries
    • Back
    • Internships
      • Back
      • Internships
      • Back
    • Family Ministries
      • Back
      • Family Ministries
      • Back
    • Kids
      • Back
      • MBC Kids
      • Back
    • Teens
      • Back
      • Teens
      • The Break
      • Rush Blog
      • Back
    • Adults
      • Back
      • Alpha Groups Initiative
      • Small Groups
      • Women
      • Adult Education
      • Young Adults
      • Senior Luncheon
      • Men
      • Radical Mentoring – Coming in September
      • Back
    • Underground Sessions
      • Back
      • Underground Sessions
      • Back
    • Care
      • Back
      • Back
    • Divorce Care
      • Back
      • Divorce Care
      • Back
    • Stephen Ministry
      • Back
      • Back
    • Missions – World Partners
      • Back
      • MBC Missions – World Partners
      • Senegal
      • First Choice
      • The Relief Bus
      • Market Street
      • Feeding Hands
      • Back
    • MBC Unhindered
      • Back
      • MBC Unhindered
      • Back
    • Little Footprints Learning Center
      • Back
      • Back
    • Back
  • media
    • Back
    • Pastors Weekly Video
      • Back
      • Updates & Connection Opportunities
      • Back
    • Pastor’s Table Blog
      • Back
      • Pastor’s Table Blog
      • Back
    • Sunday Service Live Stream
      • Back
      • MBC Live
      • Back
    • YouTube Channel
      • Back
      • YouTube
      • Back
    • Sermon Archive
      • Back
      • Sermon Archive
      • Back
    • Back
  • events
  • prayer
  • give
    • Back
    • MBC Giving
      • Back
      • give
      • Back
    • Year-End Giving for 2023
      • Back
      • Year-End Giving for 2023
      • Back
    • Give Your Time & Efforts
      • Back
      • Share your Gifts
      • Back
    • Give Help, Get Help
      • Back
      • Give Help, Get Help
      • Back
    • Support Ukraine
      • Back
      • Support Ukraine
      • Back
    • Back
  • connect
    • Back
    • Getting Connected
      • Back
      • getting connected
      • Back
    • Shared Interest Groups
      • Back
      • Shared Interest Groups
      • Back
    • Share your Gifts
      • Back
      • Share your Gifts
      • Back
    • Back
  • log in