During the fall of 1850 and the spring of 1851 the church at Mt. Bethel, under the pastoral care of the Rev. E. C. Ambler, was blessed with the most extensive revival ever known in this area. A general spiritual reawakening swept the entire countryside. Whole families were brought to a saving knowledge of Jesus Christ, and it was to accommodate these people in the Liberty Corner-Millington area that the desire to start an independent church was born. 

Some of the members of the Mt. Bethel Church met at the Pleasant Valley School (located near the present Veterans Administration property) on May 2, 1851.  At that time it was decided to organize a new Baptist Church.  On May 4th, the Mt. Bethel Church gave a letter of dismissal to 80 of its members to form a new church.  On May 20th, the new church was organized and adopted Articles of Faith (New Hampshire Confession) and a Church Covenant.  On May 21st, the Council of Recognition met with representatives of Baptist Churches from the area of New Brunswick to Morristown.  On May 24th, the members adopted “Rules of Order” and “Articles of Discipline”.

After consideration of several sites, it was decided to erect a House of Worship “at the Junction of the new road”.  Until the completion of the new church edifice on September 29, 1852, meetings were held in the Pleasant Valley School House.